logo Welcome to the Autumn 2009 On-Line Edition of
Waterlooville's Parish Magazine
logo
St George's News

Mystery Worshipper

The Sunday School’s closed
There’s a shortage of sidesmen
The Choir’s on holiday
The photocopier’s broken down
The Vicar’s gone on pilgrimage
The lights aren’t switched on
The Serving Team’s incomplete

These are just some of the reasons why I asked that St. George’s should be omitted from the Churches potentially visited by “The Mystery Worshipper”. If you remember the early days of Pompey Chimes, you’ll recall that each month a parish was checked out and a report printed for everyone to read. Sometimes the report from “The Mystery Worshipper” was very encouraging, but at other times it read like a charge sheet. Almost everything that could go wrong, it seemed, did go wrong on that particular Sunday, and the poor parish, reeling from criticism that the whole Diocese could read, had no place to reply. The damage was done - mud sticks!

The request to be omitted was heeded and in fact the regular article in Pompey Chimes was dropped. Much relief all round. Imagine my surprise, anger and frustration then, when it was discovered that “The Mystery Worshipper” had come to St. George’s Church after all - not just for a local Diocesan newspaper, but for a national website which could be viewed the world over. My utter desolation was complete when the date of the visit was realised - Low Sunday! That’s the Sunday after Easter when……

The Sunday School’s closed
There’s a shortage of sidesmen
The Choir’s on holiday
The photocopier’s broken down
The Vicar’s gone on pilgrimage
The lights aren’t switched on
The Serving Team’s incomplete

We found out that “The Mystery Worshipper” had been here as he placed a small card in the offertory and after the service it revealed who the visitor had been. Very sneaky!

The Mystery Worshipper’s report is reproduced below. It’s a very good report, so thank you to everyone who was in Church on Low Sunday. You must read which part of the service made him feel “like being in heaven” and you must be ready to welcome him again, for he ends “They seemed a friendly bunch, so I would be happy to join them”!

Fr. Mike

Mystery Worshipper report

Mystery Worshipper: Fluffy Bunny.

The church: St George the Martyr, Waterlooville, Hampshire, England.

Denomination: Church of England, Diocese of Portsmouth.

The building: St George's was consecrated in 1831. During the 1950s and 1960s the surrounding area saw extensive development, and the church couldn't cope with the resulting population growth. Plans for a new church were started and in 1970 the new church was built on the site of the old, retaining some parts of the original building. The outside looks very grey and forbidding. But do not be put off, as inside is bright, modern and almost minimalist. Over the high altar is a very dominating crucifix with Christ looking very much in torment, but still a striking piece. The organ is situated in a loft at the back of the church, and the choir (only four members) were with the organist upstairs.The church: They host an annual music festival, which from the pictures on the website looks to be a big success and loads of fun.

The neighbourhood: Waterlooville lies a bit north of Portsmouth. The village was originally known as Waitland End and consisted of only a handful of cottages. Legend has it that Wellington's soldiers stopped at a local pub for refreshment on their return journey from the Battle of Waterloo in 1815, and thus the village became known as Waterlooville. Growth continued in 1897 with the advent of the Portsmouth to Horndean light railway. By the 1960s, growth was rapid. St Georges is across the road from a modestly sized ASDA, England's second-largest supermarket chain, and behind the main shopping street of Waterlooville. The church car park is very bijou, but I parked in ASDA (handy for shopping on the way home!).

The cast: Not certain, as nowhere did it say who was doing what that I could see. However, I guessed it was the Revd Ray Chapman, honorary assistant priest.

The date & time: 19 April 2009, 10.00am.

What was the name of the service? Parish Eucharist.

How full was the building? Almost full – and I understand that the parish priest and some of the congregation were away on pilgrimage at Walsingham (I wonder if that is where some of the choir had gone to?)

Did anyone welcome you personally? I was welcomed by a chap outside the church and by two people on entering the church, where I was given the service pamphlet and a weekly news sheet.

Was your pew comfortable? Modern movable pews with thin cushions, but comfortable.

How would you describe the pre-service atmosphere? Church bells as we entered mingled with exuberant children and the more subdued chatter of the adult congregation. There was even some laughter (adult).

What were the exact opening words of the service? “Good morning. Welcome to St George's.”

What books did the congregation use during the service? BBC Songs of Praise (the hymn book); New English Hymnal; Alternative Service Book. There was also the church’s own Eucharist pamphlet and a weekly news sheet with the collect, readings, responsorial psalm, etc.

What musical instruments were played?Organ.

Did anything distract you? I chose the wrong place to sit as I was by where the small children congregate and they were very boisterous and noisy. However, I would always defend their right to be in church no matter how distracting they are, as they are the congregation of the future. One child was removed when it cried lustily. The church is very echoey and all the speakers (amplified) resonated around the space.

Was the worship stiff-upper-lip, happy clappy, or what? Middle to high. Bells but no smells. The officiating priest wore a chasuble and there were four white robed helpers. It was a sung service.

Exactly how long was the sermon? 5 minutes.

On a scale of 1-10, how good was the preacher? 8 – He spoke quite quickly, but thankfully clearly. He mentioned that he and his wife had just returned from France, where they had followed the tracks of earlier pilgrims. He also spoke about motor homes – he apparently likes motor homes.

In a nutshell, what was the sermon about? People leave tracks of pilgrims and tracks of faith. We need to follow these tracks but also lay down our own for others to follow. Jesus knows what it is to be human (“Been there, done that, got the t-shirt”) so we are never alone. Life is full of ups and downs and Christ will always be with us.

Which part of the service was like being in heaven? The sermon, and the choir's anthem, “God be in my head,” which I own up to being one of my favourites. Despite only having four women, they made a beautiful and celestial sound.

And which part was like being in... er... the other place? The children (but I still defend their right to be there). I was confused when the responsorial psalm was omitted and we went straight to a hymn without any announcement. For some unknown reason, an elderly lady sitting two rows in front of me glared at me for what felt like a good two minutes! There were no sidespeople to direct us up to communion, so I sort of followed the flow and hoped I hadn’t trodden on anyone’s toes.

What happened when you hung around after the service looking lost? An elderly gentleman gathered up my service pamphlet from me, then another invited me into the hall for coffee. The priest recognised me as a new face and was very pleasant. He asked if I was new to the parish.

How would you describe the after-service coffee? Coffee and tea with a variety of biscuits. The coffee was fair trade (fair trade jars in evidence). Lovely cups and saucers and acceptable biscuits but no one spoke to me in the hall.

How would you feel about making this church your regular (where 10 = ecstatic, 0 = terminal)?8 – They seemed a friendly bunch, so I would be happy to join them, maybe even swell the choir numbers.

Did the service make you feel glad to be a Christian? Absolutely. I left feeling spiritually recharged.

What one thing will you remember about all this in seven days time? The sermon and the boisterous children.

• The Mystery Worshipper, which produced this report, is run by shipoffools.com, the online magazine of Christian unrest. Mystery Worshippers are volunteers who visit churches of all denominations worldwide, leaving a calling card in the collection plate and posting a first-timer’s impression of services on Ship of Fools. For further reports, visit the Mystery Worshipper at: shipoffools.com.

Return to the Autumn 2009 Features page

return to Home page and main index


page last updated 10 October 2009